Thinking of going out of network? Check each plan first.
Type in your insurance plans. See how much of each plan's business you could lose before you earn less, which plan to test first, and what a membership plan changes.
These are example plans. Replace them with yours: last 12 months, one row per insurance plan.
Your insurance plans
Per plan, last 12 months: patients seen, production at your full fee, and what the plan wrote off. Your office manager can pull these from your practice software's insurance reports.
Include the 'pay today' discount if the desk gives one.
Your guess. Nobody collects 100%. Leave it below that.
How much of each plan you could lose
If you left a plan, how much of its business could go elsewhere before you'd earn less than today. Counted in treatment dollars, not heads: one crown patient leaving costs more than one cleaning patient.
Fix what you collect before you drop anything. With a 10% discount and 95% of each bill collected, Plan D pays you more than those same patients would without insurance. Leaving would lose money even if every patient stayed.
- Can lose 23%77% of its business must stay to break even.
It pays 66% of your fee today - Can lose 18%82% of its business must stay to break even.
It pays 70% of your fee today - Can lose 23%77% of its business must stay to break even.
It pays 66% of your fee today - Loses moneyIt pays more than these patients would without insurance.
It pays 90% of your fee today
See as a table
| Plan | Patients | Paid today | Business that must stay | Room to lose |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plan A | 220 | $118,000 | 77% | Can lose 23% |
| Plan B | 90 | $49,000 | 82% | Can lose 18% |
| Plan C | 35 | $18,500 | 77% | Can lose 23% |
| Plan D | 60 | $40,500 | — | Loses money |
Safest plan to test first: Plan C. It has room to lose some business and the least money at risk. The first plan you leave is there to prove the approach works, not to save the most.
Try a balance
Pick the plans you'd leave. Keep the rest. See what changes.
Your guess. Compare it with each plan's break-even above. Members are counted as the same share of its patients.
Your guess. Change it to yours.
Study: A 2024 review of 1,000+ plans found adult plans averaged about $33 a month. At your fees, the care it covers is worth $37 a month.
Your fees, for the membership value
Leaving Plan C: plus $1,849 a year.
Leaving Plan C
To break even, Plan C needs 77% of its business to stay. You assumed 85%.
See as a table
| Plans you keep | Paying directly | Membership fees | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Today | $226,000 | $0 | $0 | $226,000 |
| After | $207,500 | $15,597 | $4,752 | $227,849 |
Membership fees are part of what staying patients pay, not extra on top. Chair time freed by patients who leave isn't counted.
Before any letter goes to an insurance company
- Check you can actually end the contract. Some plans are networks rented to other networks you never signed with.
- Fix the uninsured discount first. It costs nothing and gives every plan more room.
- Have the membership plan ready, priced and recorded in your software.
- Give the front desk the words for the patient who asks.
How the numbers work
The same arithmetic our Insurance fix runs on real claims, cut down to three numbers per plan.
- Break-even
- What a plan pays you today, divided by what the same patients would pay you directly: your fee, less your uninsured discount, times the share you collect. That's the share of the plan's business, in treatment dollars, that must stay. Not a headcount: one crown patient counts for more than one cleaning patient.
- Safest first test
- A plan that could lose at least 5% of its business and still break even, with at least five patients on it and the least money at risk. The first plan you leave is there to prove the approach works.
- The collection check
- If what you'd collect from a patient paying directly (your fee, less the discount, less what never gets paid) is below what a plan pays, leaving that plan loses money even if every patient stays. Fix that first.
- Membership
- Fees from members are part of what staying patients pay, not extra income on top. What they add is a steady monthly amount.
Questions
Which PPO should I drop first?
Usually not the one that writes off the most. That plan tends to carry the most patients, so a few leaving can turn the saving into a loss. Start with a smaller plan that has room to lose some business, measure 90 days, then decide the next one.
What's a good price for a membership plan?
A 2024 review of more than 1,000 dental membership plans found adult plans averaged about $33 a month in non-rural areas. The planner also shows what the cleanings, exams and x-rays it covers are worth at your own fees.
Is this enough to decide?
No. It's a first read from numbers you typed. A real decision needs your contracts (some can't be ended the way you'd think) and your claims plan by plan. On Open Dental, our Insurance fix reads those directly.
Do you see what I type?
No. The planner runs in your browser and saves nothing. We only see your numbers if you press Send.
Want the plan-by-plan answer from your real claims?
Start with a free Practice Review. On Open Dental, the Insurance fix reads every claim and contract and gives you the order to leave in.
You'll talk to Antonio.Founder, and the person who reads your report. Built for US practices, working from Medellín on US hours.